Thursday, February 02, 2006

A third half way

Some Wanganui voters are either exceptionally astute or incredibly stupid.

Half way through the period during which voting forms can be returned, and only a third (9742) of those eligible have voted.

That, of course, is more than a third of those who will vote, since there'll always be a percentage of those who simply can't be bothered. Of those almost 10,000 people, there'll be perhaps a few hundred who know one or other of the candidates personally and are convinced they're the right person for the job no matter what the others have to offer. Fair enough.

Then there'll be a tiny percentage of those who've voted on party political lines (the Diva, Bob Walker) or because they've been told for whom to vote (the rest of diVision).

If we postulate that each of the candidates has, say, 100 friends of voting age who know them well, that's 800 voters. Then let's assume that each of those people has sufficient influence over three of their friends to convince them to vote for someone they don't really know, and is motivated enough to drum up support that way. That's 2400 votes accounted for.

So how have the other 7342 people made up their minds? What have they seen that could possibly sway them one way or another? A Phillipa Baker-Hogan sign? A Margaret Campion newspaper ad? Bren Sinclair's wheelbarrow? Either they know something the rest of the city doesn't, or they're playing the exciting new game, "Voting Roulette".

As the Chron
mildly notes "There is also the holidaytime factor. The community traditionally is hard to motivate in January which is when candidates cranked up their campaigning and the Chronicle began running profiles and exploring issues. In addition, there is theoretically a dampening effect from having two long weekends (Wellington anniversary and Waitangi Day) within the voting period."

And so deliberately delaying the calling of a by-election till that period is called... anyone?... Yes, Mr Maslin in the back there? No? Repeat after us: gerry-man-der-ing.

The Diva will be relieved to see things are back to normal in the Chron newsroom after that irritating bout of independence over Christmas.

What's more concerning in the Chron's report, however, is that Wanganui District Council electoral officer Noeline Moosman feels she has to "nudge voters into action" when the number of voting papers flowing in takes a bit of a dip.

If the buy-election was happening at a time when most people were focused on politics rather than the beach and the barbeque, and if the candidates were actually giving us any idea of what they stand for, then hurrying voters along might be appropriate.

But when most people would be hard-pressed to name a single policy espoused by each of the candidates, herding an ill-informed population towards the post box with completed voting papers in hand is bordering on irresponsible. Ms Moosman's job is, of course, to ensure a high turnout and thus to see that democracy in Wanganui gets a fair shake. But, like the rest of us, she needs to remember things are never what they seem to be when the Diva's involved.


Having shocked ourselves (and no doubt you, gentle reader) by agreeing with the Diva this week, we're about to strike a second blow: we agree with the Chron. Dave Laurence's story concludes: "Finally, there’s a hypothesis that astute voters won’t complete their voting papers until they’ve seen candidates in action at the Chronicle-organised forum on February 8".

We can only, fervently, hope he's right.

Meanwhile, don't forget to check out LawsWatch's own buy-election poll, and vote if you haven't already.

19 comments:

Anonymous said...

Marks the man ... love his ads.

Anonymous said...

yes, but P B-H has the best eyebrows

Anonymous said...

Thought we'd all decided to vote for Sarjeant supporter Margaret Campion??

Anonymous said...

Chandra's the one!

Anonymous said...

The one what ... the one what is using this by-election to push her false nails business? Should run a poll on who gets last - Bren the Christian will be at the end but who next? Heather Marion Smith?

Anonymous said...

I see Rodney Hide is going to be on Dancing with the Stars. Does that leave any room for our Mayor? I certainly hope so, it would be so good for Wanganui and we know Norm put a good word in for him. If he doesn't make it, what do you think it says about his media star, on the rise or on the decline?

Anonymous said...

have a horrible feeling the blog is losing momentum
am i right?
joan

Anonymous said...

Who wants to see more oldies on the council. It's about time someone young has given this a go. Good on Chandra for putting herself forward and promoting her buisness.

Anonymous said...

Joan - this blog lost momentum when it decided abuse was a substitute for debate. Then the mayor outed the originators & its never been the same since. Give one thing to this mayor: when he strikes, he strikes accurately.

Anonymous said...

Jay Kuten backing Margaret Campion in the Chron today. For Pete's sake someone tell him to wrap up - she needs his support like a hole in the head

Anonymous said...

Post 7.15
I think it would tell us his media profile is on the down.
If your "celebrity star" is not bright enough to get you in to reality TV shows lets face it, it's not looking good.
Theres a new celeb on the horizon every month. Laws will probably get a few more bits and pieces and that will be that.
However thats assuming he didn't make it

Anonymous said...

Yeah, good on Chandra, hope she does well. And Yeah, this blog is losing its momentum. Umm why would the Mayor go on dancing with the stars, he is already putting Wangas on the map big time and is slim and fit already. My bet is he would turn it down even if offered. And good for him. Nothing wrong with his media star, besides, why would anyone want to be on anything with Rodney Hide?

Anonymous said...

' have a horrible feeling the blog is losing momentum'

I know my friends just look at it, but don't interact.
Maybe we don't need to comments all the time.

Anonymous said...

Who wants another councillor who is there to promote self interests and her own business. Vote someone who has actually done things for Wanganui and business as a collective. As an earlier commentor said - Marks the man - he takes no crap and stands up for what is good for the city.

Anonymous said...

'My bet is he would turn it down even if offered. And good for him. Nothing wrong with his media star, besides, why would.......



Maybe they just didn't want him. Did you not know his radio ratings have really taken a full ...

Anonymous said...

Jay Kuten backing Margaret Campion in the Chron today. For Pete's sake someone tell him to wrap up - she needs his support like a hole in the head
########################################

I agree, lots of people know Campion and the good work she does, she doesn't need anyone's help.

Anonymous said...

Post 7.30pm
Do you really think the Mayor would turn down dancing with stars if offered. I don't think so He was happy to appear on two treasure island reality shows and dancing with stars is by far more popular ratings wise than both of them.
A celeb is only as good as how much they can stay in the public awareness, and that is generally through the media.
I think Laws is past his used by date celeb wise. People like Marcus Lush are the future, you would never catch him on treasure island, far too smart. Another one to watch for is News boy Jeremy Wells who does "Controversy" so much better than Laws. In fact he seems to have our Mayor in his sights, picking on him at will and for fun.

Anonymous said...

How can someone do something for the community when not given the opportunity???? How does a young person gain experience these days? It's not like anyone wants to take a young one on as an apprentice counciller. Do they!!!

Anonymous said...

Chandra's the one, nice caring lady, go chandra, marks too unfriendly, margaret past her use by date and Alan to old, saw philippa screaming at her kids the other day in the car, could she handle the stress at council??? give the young lady a go...go chandra Osborne